What is the difference between a handyman and a contractor? If you need some work done on your home, this can be an important distinction.

What a handyman does

Generally speaking a handyman will perform smaller tasks and repairs around the home. From “honey do” lists and various maintenance projects, good jobs for a handyman would be things such as:

  • Fixing leaks
  • Repairing minor electrical issues
  • Painting / trim work
  • Assembling furniture
  • Clean and repair gutters
  • Fence building or repairs
  • Repairing or replacing siding
  • Other relatively minor tasks

What a contractor does

A contractor usually takes on larger and more complex projects. This can include home renovations, remodeling, construction, major electrical and plumbing work, and other extensive projects that require specialized skills and expertise. You would likely call a contractor for job like:

  • Kitchen or bathroom remodels
  • Major plumbing or electrical work
  • Home additions / building additional dwelling units (ADU)
  • Complete home remodels
  • Projects that require structural changes to the home

Key differences between a handyman and a contractor

We’ve talked about the scope of work between the two, but some other things that distinguish what a handyman can do versus a contractor include licensing and qualifications, expertise, and cost.

When it comes to licensing and qualifications, a handyman may not be required to have a specific license for the types of tasks they perform. However, regulations vary depending on location. In Washington state, for example, a handyman is considered a specialized contractor and must be registered with the state. Handymen typically have a broad range of skills but might not be licensed in specialized trades.

Contractors, especially those who engage in specific trades such as plumbing, electrical work, or construction, often require licenses and certifications. These licenses ensure that they have the necessary training and expertise to carry out more complex and potentially risky projects.

Expertise differences

Handymen generally have a versatile skill set that covers a wide range of basic repair and maintenance tasks. They are usually more suitable for minor repairs and projects that don’t involve significant structural changes.

Contractors often have specialized training and experience in specific trades. This allows them to handle complex projects, often involving multiple phases, larger budgets, and compliance with building codes and regulations.

Cost differences

Handyman services generally have lower hourly rates compared to contractors. They are a cost-effective option for minor repairs and tasks. Contractors often charge more due to the expertise required for more complex projects. The costs may include labor, materials, permits, and other expenses.

The overlap between contractors and handymen

As is the case with many professional services, there can be overlap in the capabilities and experience of the handyman or contractor. It’s not always a black and white divide. For example, you may have a handyman that is capable and experienced in larger-scale projects such as building decks and bathroom remodels. Conversely, often contractors bring in a handyman to perform certain aspects of more complicated projects.

In our case, we are a licensed general construction contractor in Washington state, giving us unique flexibility to handle projects of various sizes.

Tips for deciding who to hire

When deciding whether to hire a handyman or contractor, there are a few things you should keep in mind.

  • Scope of work
    If you know it is going to be a small job, or you have a smaller budget, a handyman is likely the right choice. If you are unsure how large the job might end up being, it is best to get a few opinions from trusted sources. Ask people you know and check reviews of companies you are considering.

  • Check qualifications!
    Unfortunately, there are self-styled handymen and contractors out there who do not carry the proper licensure or insurance. The last thing you want is for a less than reputable worker to make changes to your home, only to have something costly go wrong and the worker vanish and not be liable for damages! It happens more than you might think.

    Fortunately, you can often avoid that by checking license status. In Washington, you can use this website to verify if a contactor has the proper credentials. There are similar resources in other states.

  • Ask to see previous work
    If you’re going to the expense to hire a handyman or contractor, ask for photo samples and explanations of similar jobs they’ve done previously.

  • Communication
    A reputable handyman or contractor should be clear and thorough in their communication about the scope and cost of the project. You should expect a free estimate, complete with a detailed plan about how the work will be done and expected cost.

    An aside: many who have done home repairs know that unanticipated problems can arise that add more to project. When that occurs, a trustworthy worker will bring the problem to you and proactively offer solutions and revised costs. That is why it is so important to be careful to check qualifications and reviews!

In conclusion, the main difference between a handyman and a contractor lies in the scale and complexity of the work they undertake, their expertise, and the licensing requirements. If you have small, simple repairs, a handyman might be a suitable choice. For larger projects or those involving specialized skills, a contractor is more appropriate. Always ensure that whoever you hire is qualified and licensed as required by local regulations.